The Question of God and Evil


I hadn’t realized it, but April is Holocaust month, a time to remember and think about the unimaginable events that marked our history in the last century.

Ron Rosenbaum, writing in “The Chronicle of Higher Education,” (The Naked Truth), wrestles with the meaning of the Holocaust. Wikipedia tells me that in the ’70s and ’80s, he spent years researching Adolph Hitler, finally publishing Explaining Hitler: The Search for the Origins of His Evil in 1988. His  life as a Jewish man, and a thinking, feeling human being has been haunted by the Holocaust. It, more than any other single event, has raised the question of evil and God.  The study of the question even has its own field of study, called theodicy. How, it asks, can a God who is worshiped as an all-powerful, all-knowing, and loving deity,a God who  is able to intervene in history and has time and again, be reconciled with the evil that pervades our world? Why would such a God permit the Holocaust?


Rosenbaum takes the attempts to answer this question one by one, and finds them empty, sometimes obscene, and always unconvincing. More, he agrees with the renegade Rabbi Richard Rubenstein who wrote, “Jewish history has written the final chapter in the terrible story of the God of History. And the pathetic hope of coming to grips with Auschwitz through the framework of traditional Judaism will never be realized.”

Or, as Bob Dylan put it, “hitler did not change history. Hitler was history….”

Rosenbaum’s essay in this instance has to do with his passionate opposition to every attempt to explain away this awful God, and the offense one of his listeners took to his words.  My concerns take another direction.

When I finished reading Rosenbaum’s piece, I looked at the comments that followed–dozens of them, pursuing the same convoluted debates the author had already taken apart. Rosenbaum had been talking specifically about the God he knew as a Jew, the creator-God who acts in history, but most of the ranting men and women professed no such faith. And that’s why I wondered why none of them entertained the answer I’d given to the question of evil years ago.

I’d studied philosophy of religion on the undergraduate and graduate levels, so it wasn’t a question I hadn’t thought about. If God or the Divine couldn’t be both good and all-powerful, then it seemed to me it was obvious that the Divine was love and goodness, and not all-powerful. I think the point of the crucified son of God is exactly that: a demonstration of  Divine love rather than power, God as one with humanity, weak, meek, with another kind of strength perhaps, but not that of the thundering Deity of the Old (and New!) Testaments.

Certainly, that answer isn’t original with me, so why, I wonder, why didn’t any of those ranting letter-writers consider that possibility? For those who believe, does God have to be all-powerful? By definition? Is our culture hung up on the idea of power? I could go on, but I’d love to hear what my readers think!

Author: latefruit

I am forever writing the great American novel, practicing the piano (in hopes of joining an amateur string quartet someday), gardening, and now, since I've gotten old when I wasn't looking, trying to figure out what that means.

2 thoughts on “The Question of God and Evil”

  1. I think that Man is part of God, just like everything else that exists. Like the all-enveloping God, he is a trinity. His soul (father) is eternal, his body (son) is born of the Earth and remains on Earth, his mind (spirit, ghost) is a bridge to all that exists. Man can use his mind in any way that he chooses. Thoughts create. If his thoughts are evil, they create evil things. If they are good, they create good things. His thoughts influence himself and others. They influence everything that exists. Man’s supreme power is his mind but he does not seem to be conscious of this. He persists in limiting his studies to the material world, neglecting his astounding mind. Man’s mind is the key to Man’s knowledge of all that exists, in other words, God. We are connected to and part of all existence. I think that God is the sum total of all that exists. I like to say that the Earth is a cell in God’s body but that implies that God has a body. If that is so, then we are part of it.

  2. Good stated to everyone that you take a huge risk to want to be alive. If you do, it will be rewarding and also sad. If I give you life, you will have to learn to hate me, harbor grudges against me, even take my name in vain.But you will be punished, and I will reward you. Not always when you want.

    God is not a friendly God. He is a very harsh, God. Like his wind, very lonely, and solitary. Experiences that can’t be shared with others.

    God has his dlimema. Bring you into the world, you will suffer. Man is able to infinitiely suffer. God is not able to, so he didn’t take that role. He was able to be divine energy. We are not. We are conduits of energy. So we are alive for a short time, then die.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: